The Space Vault
Albert Bishai @annunakkki

🕎✡️✝️☪️FEASTING ON THE CARCASS OF MAGA

13 minPart 32 speakers

Speakers

TalkingOn stage

2 accounts on stage. Tap a bar to play from there.

  1. Albert Bishai @annunakkki Host

    On stage 0:00–13:05Talked 13 min5 linesShow their lines

  2. True Scottish Warrior @Scot_Bast1314

    On stage 0:00–13:05Didn’t speak

Transcript

6 lines
0:00
Albert Bishai @annunakkki

anti-Muslim propaganda for months and there was many sources of that but one of the sources and a big source did include this campaign in terms of just about the sums of money i mean meta says that there's approximately 1.2 million um dollars in spending during the first phase alone before it then moved more heavily onto youtube and tiktok um and then there's other measures so you know i mean what kind of scale are we talking about so again the only the only the confirmed spend that we have is from from two sources right so i want to say something about next report so we released the first part of our report back in 2024. this was before method published their report into the campaign and meta knew we were about to publish our publisher we even spoke to method beforehand because they wanted to see what we knew they were a bit worried um and we told them everything we were going to write and i even asked them i was like so how many people saw this campaign and they refused to tell me um but the report that they did publish after us was the only thing that they said that was of value really was that this campaign cost 1.2 million dollars for ads that's just ads and that was the first phase okay um so that was and and the other sum the other thing we have is from an independent it was a commercial ad tracker called ad clarity we have that information phase one because they had a free trial and that gives a similar figure okay other than that we do not know how to spend because one meta have not released a subsequent report into this campaign they've released reports they have not mentioned this report right youtube haven't mentioned anything and tiktok have not mentioned anything so what we've done we took what we knew about how many people saw the first part of the campaign and basically we knew how many people saw it we knew the cost so then we created projected figures based on that to estimate the remaining campaign okay so from that we figured that there's the minimum cost is about five million dollars up to about eight million right we estimate right um but that would just be for ad costs and it's probably a really big undercount right you know similar operations have cost tens of millions of dollars right but we're trying to be conservative in how we estimate this but we could be you know the the at cost alone is between five and eight million dollars uh since 2023 uh and that includes guessing or arranging estimating from about half a billion exposures to almost a billion right because we've created a billion exposures that's like one in every fucking million seven and a half uh one in every seven people on the planet saw between half a billion and 833 million exposures right huge range uh but the minimum cost of this is going to be astronomical and that's just for ads that doesn't include contracting companies paying the relevant pr agencies or anything like that israel let's talk about israel what is the forensic evidence pointing towards israel as a source of this campaign uh common sense um a no shit sherlock kind of situation i don't know and every single time there's a bare shit in the woods is the pope catholic kind of comes to mind right really interesting there's three levels of kind of evidence here there's the technical evidence um um there's the narrative evidence and there's the um common sense evidence right so focus mostly on

3:05

the the technical evidence captain obvious evidence in the first phase one dimension of this campaign was that sock puppet network so a bunch of accounts pretending to be someone else were making edits to wikipedia now this is a common tactic in information warfare you try to edit the wikipedia page of your enemy or your friend but make them look bad or make them look good and when we first did our investigation in 2024 we found a sock puppet account that was editing pages about cata basically saying cata was trying to maximize europe with soft power muscle brotherhood a few months ago i revisited that and i saw that a wikipedia check user sort of one of the people with high administration access in wikipedia had done an investigation and found out that one account was actually part of a network account that were making edits as part of this campaign what's interesting about that is those accounts were hidden behind an ip address based in germany call it proxy so they it looked like a german ip address but this was just a proxy ip address so they know it's a proxy it knows people are just using like a vpn essentially to hide their ip but whoever was doing it there was a mistake so sometimes the vpn dropped the proxy dropped and when that happened it revealed that the people making the edits had an israeli ip address now this israeli ip address wasn't a proxy address it was a real basically fixed line israel israeli address so it was coming from israel that's one thing and it's arguably not the strongest attribution but it's pretty significant the second and perhaps more important is metadata from telegram so telegram most people don't know so you know when you use social media like x or youtube you upload a video or an image and it strips the metadata right so the metadata would be like you know is this owen jones's computer where was this photo taken you know gps location that's all embedded in the metadata of the image it strips it away but on telegram there's an option to post and send files if you send files as opposed to sending a media file it preserves the whole file including the metadata so when meta shut down aspects of the campaign it moved to telegram and so they created a telegram channel where they were posting all these videos and i just thought you know i'll go through these in the off channels right uh because sometimes you know people make mistakes the russians have sometimes done this where they make mistakes and reveal information i downloaded all the videos and i analyzed them and sure enough there was a lot of xmp data which is like this data attached to video files and in that you know if you make a video as you do obviously for the show there's all sorts of information in there like when you edited it what program you use the name of your laptop right and i found all this information there was literally evidence of thousands of edits there was so many edits and the time of each edits i could actually recreate the working week of those involved so the working week firstly aligned with an israeli working week but you know that's not necessarily saying right because it could also be lebanon it could be the gulf um but the names there was a bunch of hebrew names and hebrew nicknames that were one was the name of a portable drive so like a usb drive that someone had plugged in the others were names of computers that uh was specifically hebrew some of the text was hebrew and yeah it was it was it was pretty clear that this had uh israeli origins but what was really interesting is that one of the names um one of the names that was in this metadata was the same as shughi d so shughi d kogni well i mean shughi d was a name but uh this this name it's quite specific match the professional name of a well-known israeli graphic designer who does video campaigning videos for a number of people this guy's worked all over africa you can go on his

6:07

portfolio and you see he's he's worked in eswatini right he's worked in kenya he's worked in mozambique doing election campaigning videos for election candidates who have hired various israeli companies to do their promotional stuff right so that was really interesting we had this name and this guy is connected to a company called timor consulting and percepto international percepto international uh are one of these israeli influence companies they sort of were well known because they worked in south africa trying to smear the international community the red cross um but the point here like when when i found this i was like it's very there's a high likelihood that this guy is the same person as the the shughi d who makes these campaign videos so we were working with lamond uh when we were about to release a report lamond reached out to shughi d to ask for comments and he didn't reply i subsequently reached out for shughi d who has not replied um to confirm that it is him but i have a high level of confidence that is the same person i certainly have a very high level of content confidence that the campaign originated in israel based on this another level of this apart from technical stuff is the narrative right so who has an interest in smear and qataran muslims and who has a track record of smear and qataran muslims you know the the main candidate for that would be uh israel right because we've seen this happen before in one attributed case another investigation i worked on and it was confirmed by the new york times is that the ministry of diaspora affairs of israel who's head amichai chicley um they contracted the tel aviv-based pr firm called stoic who launched a campaign that basically put out anti-muslim anti-migrant propaganda towards north america in canada right so that was and there was also an anti-catar dimension to that campaign too right so they have a track record of doing that and there's a third thing that i just want to mention which is also kind of interesting there was a harat piece recently that talked about an aborted attempt by a number of israeli uh people in the influence industry and government officials to create an anti-catar campaign after october the 7th right and the campaign that they described was almost identical to the beginning of the campaign that we've documented however the reporting on the article was was that that campaign was aborted right but at the same time obviously there was this campaign that happened because it was happening so my take on that is that someone else took over the helm of that campaign and some of the people who were in discussion about that campaign are involved in this it was just moved to a different part maybe of the the israeli government right and interestingly one of the people who was in that whatsapp group discussing this campaign was the head of one of the heads of percepto international one of the firms that is linked to this graphic designer it's sorry information done yeah pretty no but pretty decisive um circumstantial evidence i mean people say circumstantial evidence but i mean we're talking confidence levels right so you know like i said high confidence that this originated in israel for sure uh i would say moderate high confidence that the the people involved are the people we believe to be involved um but yeah it's unless you have a smoking gun someone coming are you suggesting that jews would engage in this in an active deceitful smear campaign you don't say that's outrageous john maury maury you better call you better dial up jonathan greenblatt baruch hashem the anti-semites are coming out of the woodwork with cyber security always talk about levels of confidence

9:07

yeah i think that might be an expert's sense but i think the regular person as it were would look at that and think well it's obvious what's happened there if i'm honest i mean like listen like what's fun just as an aside right when we were analyzing i know you guys are all shocked right this is shocking news to to all of you right this must be a massive psyop you know i think at some point it became so obvious from the narrative that this was that this was just aside from the narrative we know there's been multiple israel-based disinformation campaigns i mean for example uh the french security agency virginium and yeah accused an israeli tech company called black cord interfering in multiple elections including scotland against the snp in france in the new york mayoral election when they approached comment black people just wipe existence from the internet and we know as well about um um and ad campaigns originally officially from israel targeting the likes of medicines on frontier under the palestine the un's palestine refugee agency uh we know about a a think tank which was a fictional u.s think tank created in order to gain chat gbt and other chatbots and you know that israel's ministry diaspora affairs launched a campaign involving hundreds of fake accounts dating to be real american voters promoting pros or messages on x and facebook i mean we could go on team horgy was another one which came actually before the genocide which again black cube is another founded by israel and is right so that's an israeli private intelligence firm which we know intervened in slovenia where i had a pro-palestinian government we could go on i mean you go on and on and on forever absolutely and you're right and that context is really important when i'm talking about like the the motive right um and you know the campaigns you mentioned are all of that i mean you mentioned for example the gaming of llm i think there's one thing that's important to distinguish here there's the sort of public campaign so we know for example the attempts to influence chat gpt with you know rag poisoning we know the israeli ministry of foreign affairs has contracted companies like uh harvest media and this clock tower to do that we know that because they filed fara filings right the team borje that you mentioned and you know companies like nso group who sell pegases and this campaign operate in a secret space right they're all doing propaganda they're all doing disinformation but some quote-unquote is more legitimate than others in the sense that yeah you can say that we're going to try and gain this llm to make it more pro-israel yeah that's propaganda but they're still not as bad as saying okay we're going to do this nasty racist anti-muslim propaganda that is probably contravening laws in the european union and so you have to hide your hand with that right so there's the hidden dimension and it's highly more public all of it is egregious but some is clearly there's an attempt to hide it because it's so so uh well might be illegal but also just overtly racist and and as another point i think some it's all overtly racist oh that the muslims are going for a this is what i this is what i've seen and meta is the worst

12:12

meta is hands down the worst they the muslims want to make no dog zones across america right you're gonna attack you're you're you're going at a very sensitive you're going on a very sensitive area americans love their dogs right they know what they're fucked they know what the fuck they're doing and this is a big big deal oh what kind of person we we don't like people that don't like dogs i don't trust people that don't like dogs it's a sensitive area and you know it's like the uh the underbelly the soft underbelly where you where you can make some you know inroads into fanning that islamophobic sentiment right because what people don't want

13:04

fanning that islamophobic sentiment right because what people don't like to do is they're not going to

🕎✡️✝️☪️FEASTING ON THE CARCASS OF MAGAAlbert Bishai
0:00
13:05